S/4HANA Migration

S/4HANA Migration Steps in SAP HANA

The migration to SAP S/4HANA essentially means moving your existing SAP ERP (ECC) system to run on the SAP HANA database and adopting the new S/4HANA application code and simplified data model.

There are primarily three main approaches to migrate to S/4HANA:

Greenfield (New Implementation): Starting from scratch with a completely new S/4HANA system. This is suitable for companies that want to re-engineer their business processes, simplify their landscape, and leverage all S/4HANA innovations. Data migration involves extracting, transforming, and loading only necessary data (master data and open items) into the new system.
Brownfield (System Conversion): Technically converting an existing SAP ECC system to S/4HANA. This approach preserves existing configurations, historical data, and custom code, minimizing disruption to current business processes. The underlying database is migrated to HANA, and the application code is replaced. This is often the most common path for existing SAP customers.
Selective Data Transition / Hybrid: A more flexible approach, often for large enterprises with complex landscapes, allowing selective migration of specific entities (e.g., company codes, ledgers) or a phased approach. This can combine elements of both Greenfield and Brownfield.

This document will focus primarily on the Brownfield (System Conversion) approach, as it's the most common for existing ECC customers and directly involves a "migration" of the existing system onto HANA and S/4HANA.

Phases and Detailed Steps for S/4HANA System Conversion (Brownfield)

A typical S/4HANA system conversion project is divided into several phases:

Phase 1: Project Preparation and Discovery (Pre-Migration)

Define Scope and Strategy:
- Migration Approach: Greenfield, Brownfield, or Hybrid? (Decision already made for Brownfield in this context).
- Deployment Option: On-Premise, Cloud (Public/Private), Hybrid.
- Target S/4HANA Release: Which version of S/4HANA (e.g., 2023, 2024) will be the target?
- Project Plan & Team: Establish project governance, timeline, resources (internal, external), and roles.
S/4HANA Readiness Check:
- Tool: SAP Readiness Check for S/4HANA.
- Purpose: Analyzes your current ECC system for compatibility with the target S/4HANA release.
- Outputs:
  - Simplification Items: Identifies mandatory changes due to simplifications in S/4HANA (e.g., changes in financials, logistics). These must be addressed.
  - Custom Code Analysis: Identifies custom code that is incompatible or needs adaptation (e.g., due to HANA database changes, new data model, removed functionalities).
  - Business Process Impact: Highlights areas where existing business processes will be affected.
  - Sizing Recommendations: Provides initial sizing estimates for the HANA database.
  - Add-on Compatibility: Checks installed add-ons for S/4HANA compatibility.
  - Fiori Readiness: Assesses Fiori usage and potential.
Data Volume Management (DVM) & Data Archiving:
- Purpose: Reduce the data footprint of the source ECC system before conversion. Smaller databases mean faster conversion times, lower hardware costs, and better performance.
- Activities: Identify and archive old, unused data. Delete obsolete data.
Pre-requisite Software & Hardware Review:
- Source ECC Version: Must be ECC 6.0 (any EHP).
- Unicode Conversion: The source ECC system must be Unicode compliant. If not, a separate Unicode conversion project is required beforehand.
- Hardware Sizing: Ensure the target hardware/cloud infrastructure meets SAP HANA and S/4HANA requirements (RAM, CPU, storage, I/O). Use SAP Quick Sizer and T-Shirt Sizing, followed by detailed DVM-based sizing.
- Operating System: Ensure the OS is supported for HANA (e.g., SLES, RHEL).
Customer-Vendor Integration (CVI) for Business Partners:
- Mandatory: In S/4HANA, customers and vendors are unified into a single Business Partner (BP) object.
- Activity: CVI implementation must be completed in the source ECC system before conversion. This involves mapping existing customer/vendor master data to the BP data model.
Functional Assessment and Fit/Gap Analysis:
- Purpose: Understand the impact of Simplification Items on current business processes.
- Activities: Analyze required changes, new functionalities, and potential for process re-engineering. Identify gaps and plan for solutions (standard S/4HANA, Fiori apps, custom developments).

Phase 2: Technical Conversion (Execution Phase)

This phase primarily uses the Software Update Manager (SUM) with Database Migration Option (DMO).

Install/Update HANA Database:
- If the source ECC is not yet on HANA, install a new HANA database on the target hardware.
- If ECC is already on HANA, ensure the HANA database version is compatible with the target S/4HANA release and perform any necessary HANA database upgrades.
Apply Pre-conversion Notes:
- Implement specific SAP Notes required for the chosen S/4HANA release. These often prepare the system for the conversion process.
Perform Custom Code Adaptation:
- Tool: ABAP Test Cockpit (ATC), Custom Code Migration Worklist (CMWL).
- Activities: Adapt incompatible custom code identified in the Readiness Check. This includes syntax fixes, usage of new APIs, replacing obsolete functionalities (e.g., financial tables, material ledger). This can be a significant effort.
Execute SUM DMO:
- This is the core technical conversion tool. It combines the upgrade of the SAP application with the database migration (if not already on HANA).
- Steps within SUM DMO:
  - Initialization: Set up the SUM directory and configuration.
  - Checks: Performs numerous system checks (e.g., consistency, free space, prerequisites).
  - Pre-processing: Creates shadow system, applies basis stack, adapts custom code, performs pre-conversion data transformations (e.g., creating compatibility views). This phase can be done with minimal downtime.
  - Downtime Phase: This is the critical cutover window.
    - Converts the database to HANA (if not already).
    - Performs the actual data migration and transformation into the new S/4HANA data model (e.g., ACDOCA for financials).
    - Activates new S/4HANA objects.
    - Completes custom code activation.
  - Post-processing: Finalizes the conversion, performs consistency checks, and generates new objects.
Post-Conversion Activities:
- Activate Business Functions: Activate new S/4HANA-specific business functions.
- Apply SAP Notes: Implement any post-conversion SAP Notes.
- Optimize Performance: Run performance-related reports, update statistics.
- Security & Authorization: Adjust roles and authorizations for new S/4HANA Fiori apps and simplified transactions.
- Fiori Configuration: Configure and activate relevant Fiori apps and Fiori Launchpad.

Phase 3: Testing and Go-Live

Functional Testing:
- Unit Testing: Test individual functionalities and processes.
- Integration Testing: Test end-to-end business processes across modules.
- User Acceptance Testing (UAT): Business users validate that the new system meets their requirements.
- Regression Testing: Ensure existing functionalities still work correctly.
- Performance Testing: Verify system performance meets SLAs under load.
Data Validation:
- Ensure data consistency and integrity after conversion, especially for financial and logistics data.
Cutover Planning:
- Detailed plan for the final production cutover, including backup strategy, downtime estimation, and fallback plan.
Go-Live:
- Execute the cutover plan, bring the new S/4HANA system live.
Hypercare:
- Intensive support phase immediately after go-live to address any immediate issues.

Important Configurations to Keep in Mind

These configurations span across different tools and phases:

Readiness Check Configuration:
- Ensure the source ECC system has the necessary SAP Notes and ABAP reports implemented to run the Readiness Check correctly.
- Generate up-to-date system usage data for accurate custom code analysis and sizing.
SUM DMO Parameters:
- Downtime Optimization: SUM offers various options to minimize downtime. Understand the phases (pre-processing, downtime, post-processing) and leverage parallel processing, nZDM, etc.
- Memory/CPU Allocation: Configure SUM with adequate memory and CPU for its processes to run efficiently. Incorrect sizing can lead to long runtimes or even failures.
- _DB.migration.active: This parameter in the SUM profile indicates a DMO run.
- _DB.HDB.compatibility_mode: Relevant if migrating from other databases to HANA.
HANA Database Sizing and Configuration:
- Memory: Ensure sufficient RAM for the HANA database based on the Readiness Check sizing. Oversizing can be costly, undersizing leads to performance issues (paging, OOMs).
- CPU: Adequate CPU cores to handle the workload.
- Storage: Fast I/O for data and log volumes. Separate volumes for data, log, and backup.
- Parameter Adjustments: Review HANA parameters (global.ini, indexserver.ini, etc.) for optimal S/4HANA performance.
  - base_port: For multi-tenant setup.
  - total_memory_limit: To control memory usage.
- Network: High-speed network for distributed HANA systems or between application and DB.
Custom Code Management:
- ADAPTER_TRANSPORT_TOOL: For transferring adapted custom code from a sandbox to other systems.
- ATC Central Check System: Establish an ATC system early for efficient custom code analysis across multiple systems.
Fiori Launchpad and Fiori Apps:
- Gateway Configuration: Proper setup of SAP Gateway (Embedded or Hub deployment) for Fiori connectivity.
- Role and Catalog Management: Assign appropriate Fiori catalogs and groups to users.
- OData Service Activation: Activate necessary OData services for Fiori apps.
- Caching: Configure Fiori cache settings for optimal performance.
Business Partner (BP) Configuration:
- Synchronization: Ensure robust synchronization settings between Customer/Vendor and Business Partner via CVI.
- Number Ranges: Align internal/external number ranges for BP, Customer, and Vendor.
- BP Roles: Configure required BP roles for different business processes.
Data Consistency Checks:
- Financial Reconciliation: Special attention to financial data consistency after conversion (e.g., new Universal Journal Entry ACDOCA). Tools like FAGL_RFWERESL for reconciliation.
- Migration of Master Data: Ensure data consistency for new master data objects (e.g., Material Master length increase).
Security and Authorization:
- Role Redesign: S/4HANA often necessitates a redesign of traditional SAP roles due to new Fiori apps and simplified transactions.
- Fiori Catalogs/Groups: Ensure proper authorization objects are linked to Fiori artifacts.
- Principle of Least Privilege: Implement robust authorization concepts.

30 Interview Questions and Answers (One-Liner) for S/4HANA Migration Steps

Q: What is the primary database for SAP S/4HANA?
- A: SAP HANA database.
Q: Name the three main approaches for S/4HANA migration.
- A: Greenfield (New Implementation), Brownfield (System Conversion), Selective Data Transition.
Q: Which migration approach is best for completely re-engineering business processes?
- A: Greenfield.
Q: Which migration approach preserves existing configurations and historical data?
- A: Brownfield (System Conversion).
Q: What is the main tool used for a Brownfield S/4HANA conversion?
- A: Software Update Manager (SUM) with Database Migration Option (DMO).
Q: What is the purpose of SAP Readiness Check for S/4HANA?
- A: To analyze an ECC system's compatibility and identify impacts for S/4HANA conversion.
Q: What are "Simplification Items" in S/4HANA migration?
- A: Mandatory changes in S/4HANA due to data model or functional simplifications.
Q: What is the mandatory prerequisite for the source ECC system regarding Unicode?
- A: It must be Unicode compliant.
Q: What is CVI, and why is it mandatory for S/4HANA conversion?
- A: Customer-Vendor Integration, unifies customer/vendor into Business Partner (BP).
Q: Which tool is used to analyze and adapt custom ABAP code for S/4HANA?
- A: ABAP Test Cockpit (ATC) and Custom Code Migration Worklist (CMWL).
Q: What is the new universal journal entry table in S/4HANA Finance?
- A: ACDOCA.
Q: What is the role of Data Volume Management (DVM) in S/4HANA migration?
- A: To reduce database size before conversion, improving performance and reducing costs.
Q: What happens during the "Downtime Phase" of SUM DMO?
- A: Actual data conversion, application upgrade, and new object activation occur.
Q: What are the primary tools for S/4HANA sizing?
- A: SAP Quick Sizer and detailed DVM analysis.
Q: Why is Fiori relevant to S/4HANA?
- A: It's the new user experience (UX) and primary interface for S/4HANA.
Q: What is "Hypercare" in a migration project?
- A: The intensive support phase immediately following go-live.
Q: Does S/4HANA support all traditional ECC transactions (T-codes)?
- A: No, many are replaced or integrated into Fiori apps due to simplifications.
Q: What is the key difference in master data between ECC and S/4HANA concerning customer/vendor?
- A: They are unified into the Business Partner (BP) in S/4HANA.
Q: What is the purpose of Pre-conversion SAP Notes?
- A: To prepare the source system for the conversion process.
Q: What kind of testing is crucial before S/4HANA go-live?
- A: Functional, Integration, User Acceptance (UAT), Performance, Regression.
Q: What is the significance of the listenip parameter in HANA DB for S/4HANA connectivity?
- A: It defines which IP addresses HANA listens on for connections.
Q: How does total_memory_limit affect HANA DB performance during S/4HANA operations?
- A: Controls the maximum memory consumed by HANA, preventing system instability.
Q: What are some common post-conversion activities?
- A: Activating Business Functions, applying Notes, Fiori configuration, security adjustments.
Q: What is the main benefit of a "Clean Core" strategy in S/4HANA?
- A: Minimizing custom code to simplify upgrades and reduce technical debt.
Q: What is the primary risk of not performing Data Volume Management before conversion?
- A: Longer downtime during conversion, higher hardware costs, and potential performance issues.
Q: Which component handles Fiori connectivity from the S/4HANA backend?
- A: SAP Gateway (either embedded or hub deployment).
Q: What is the purpose of FAGL_RFWERESL in S/4HANA finance post-conversion?
- A: Financial reconciliation to ensure data consistency in ACDOCA.
Q: Can you migrate directly from any ECC version to S/4HANA?
- A: No, minimum is ECC 6.0 (any EHP).
Q: What's a key consideration for S/4HANA deployment in the cloud?
- A: Cloud readiness assessment and alignment with cloud provider capabilities.
Q: Why is careful authorization adjustment important post-S/4HANA conversion?
- A: New Fiori apps and simplified transactions require updated roles and privileges.

5 Scenario-Based Hard Questions and Answers for S/4HANA Migration Steps

Scenario: You are leading a Brownfield S/4HANA conversion project. During the "Downtime Phase" of SUM DMO in the sandbox environment, the process halts repeatedly due to "insufficient memory" errors on the HANA database, even though initial sizing indicated enough RAM. You notice the indexserver service consumes an unexpectedly high amount of memory.
- Q: What are the most likely reasons for this memory issue during the downtime phase, and what specific troubleshooting and mitigation steps would you take without immediately increasing physical RAM?
- A:
  - Most Likely Reasons:
    1. Ineffective Data Volume Management (DVM): Despite initial sizing, the actual data to be converted/transformed (especially the intermediate tables generated by SUM DMO for financial data migration to ACDOCA or other simplification items) is much larger than anticipated, possibly due to unarchived historical data or very high number of open items.
    2. Unoptimized Custom Code: Some custom programs or transformations, even if syntactically adapted, might be inefficiently written for HANA and consume excessive memory during the conversion process, particularly if they are triggered as part of the SUM DMO's ABAP execution steps.
    3. Missing Pre-conversion Notes/Corrections: Specific SAP Notes that optimize the conversion process or fix memory-related bugs during data transformation might be missing.
    4. HANA Parameter Misconfiguration: HANA memory parameters (global.ini, indexserver.ini, especially total_memory_limit or statement_memory_limit) are too restrictive for the intense data transformations happening in SUM DMO, or other non-essential services are consuming memory.
    5. Long-Running Transactions/Processes: Though less common during downtime, if background processes or very large transactions are attempting to run (e.g., from old schedule), they might compete for memory.
  - Troubleshooting and Mitigation Steps:
    1. Analyze HANA Traces & Alerts:
      - Check indexserver traces (e.g., indexserver_<hostname>.*.trc) for specific OOM (Out Of Memory) dumps or errors. The OOM dump will identify the problematic component, SQL statement, or table.
      - Review HANA Alerts (M_ALERTS_) for memory-related issues.
    2. Review SUM Logs:
      - Examine the SUM DMO logs (LOG_*.XML, SAPup_*.log) to pinpoint the exact phase and transformation step where the memory issue occurs. This will tell you which table conversion or program is causing it.
    3. Re-evaluate DVM and Data Profile:
      - Confirm the actual data volume in the sandbox compared to source. Re-run DB02 reports or HANA_Tables_Size_in_Memory scripts on source.
      - If possible, perform more aggressive data archiving/deletion in the source system (for subsequent iterations).
    4. Optimize HANA Parameters (Temporarily for Conversion):
      - Increase total_memory_limit (if not at max): Temporarily increase the total_memory_limit for the indexserver in global.ini or indexserver.ini (e.g., to 90% of physical RAM) only for the duration of the conversion. This is a quick fix, but ensure you revert it post-conversion.
      - Increase statement_memory_limit (if a specific query is problematic): If OOM traces point to a single, very large SQL statement, consider temporarily increasing this.
      - Disable Unnecessary Services: During conversion, temporarily stop any non-essential HANA services (e.g., XS classic/advanced, if not directly needed by SUM) to free up memory.
    5. Implement Missing SAP Notes:
      - Search SAP Support Portal for known memory issues during S/4HANA conversion for your specific source/target release. There are often specific notes that fix performance or memory consumption during certain transformation steps.
    6. Analyze and Tune Problematic SQL/Custom Code:
      - If the OOM dump or trace points to specific SQL statements or custom code, investigate their logic. Work with ABAP developers to optimize these statements for HANA (e.g., pushing down calculations, avoiding loops over large internal tables, using CDS views where appropriate).
    7. Increase SUM Parallelization (Cautiously): While more parallelization usually speeds things up, if memory is the issue, reducing parallelization for certain phases in SUM DMO might help by reducing concurrent memory demands, albeit at the cost of longer overall downtime. This is a trade-off.
Scenario: Your organization is planning a Brownfield S/4HANA conversion. The CVI (Customer-Vendor Integration) project, which is a mandatory prerequisite, is running into significant issues. You have numerous existing custom fields and enhancements in customer and vendor master data in ECC, and the CVI synchronization reports are failing or producing inconsistent data in the Business Partner (BP) records.
- Q: What are the key challenges posed by custom fields/enhancements during CVI, and what detailed steps would you take to ensure a successful and consistent CVI implementation before the S/4HANA conversion?
- A:
  - Key Challenges Posed by Custom Fields/Enhancements during CVI:
    1. Data Mapping Complexity: Standard CVI mapping might not cover custom fields, requiring manual mapping rules or custom extensions.
    2. Inconsistent Data: Custom fields often lack the robust validation and consistency checks of standard fields, leading to quality issues that surface during BP synchronization.
    3. Missing BAPI/BAdI Implementations: If custom logic modifies customer/vendor data upon creation/change, equivalent logic might be missing or incorrectly implemented for Business Partner BAPIs/BAdIs.
    4. Custom Table/Structure Integration: Custom tables or structures directly linked to customer/vendor master data need to be properly integrated into the BP data model.
    5. Number Range Mismatch: Custom logic for number ranges (internal/external) on customer/vendor might conflict with BP number ranges.
    6. Impact on Dependent Objects: Custom enhancements might affect other objects (e.g., sales orders, purchase orders) that rely on customer/vendor data, potentially breaking after CVI.
    7. Data Volume: Large volumes of custom data increase CVI processing time and error potential.
  - Detailed Steps for Successful CVI Implementation:
    1. Thorough Assessment (Discovery Phase):
      - Identify all Custom Fields/Enhancements: Use tools like SE11, SE80, SE15, and custom code analysis (ATC) to identify every custom field, table, BAdI, user exit, and report related to customer and vendor master data.
      - Business Justification: For each custom enhancement, determine if it's still needed, can be replaced by S/4HANA standard, or absolutely requires re-implementation. Decommission unnecessary customizations.
      - Data Profiling & Cleansing: Analyze the data quality of custom fields. Implement data cleansing activities (e.g., remove duplicates, standardize formats, fill missing mandatory fields) in ECC before CVI.
    2. CVI Configuration & Mapping:
      - Activate Business Functions: Ensure all relevant CVI-related business functions are activated (e.g., FIN_GL_CI_1, AP_CVI_BF_1).
      - Define BP Roles: Map existing customer/vendor account groups to appropriate Business Partner roles (e.g., FLCU00 for customer, FLVN00 for vendor).
      - Number Range Setup: Configure number range synchronization between customer/vendor and BP. Decide if BP internal/external number ranges will match existing customer/vendor.
      - Custom Field Mapping (Customer/Vendor to BP Extension): Use standard extension mechanisms (e.g., BDT - Business Data Toolset, custom BAdIs like CVI_CUSTOM_MAPPER) to map custom fields to BP extension structures (e.g., using AD_CUSTOMER/AD_VENDOR for customer/vendor data, and BUT000 for general BP data).
    3. Development and Adaptation:
      - Adapt Custom Logic: Re-implement or adapt any custom logic (BAdIs, user exits, function modules) that were triggered during customer/vendor creation/change to work with the Business Partner framework. This might involve new BAdIs specific to BP.
      - Custom Table/Structure Handling: Ensure custom tables that referenced customer/vendor IDs are updated to reference BP GUIDs or BP numbers as appropriate, or that compatibility views are created.
    4. Test Cycle (Iterative Process):
      - Sandbox/Development: Perform initial CVI synchronization in a sandbox/development system.
      - Use CVI Reports: Use standard CVI synchronization reports (e.g., MDS_LOAD_COCKPIT, CVI_FS_CHECK_CUSTOMIZING, CVI_CHECK_ALL) to identify errors and inconsistencies.
      - Regression Testing: Test dependent processes (e.g., sales order creation, purchase order processing) that use customer/vendor master data to ensure they function correctly with the new BP data.
      - Data Validation: Verify the consistency and completeness of migrated BP data (e.g., ensure all fields are mapped, no data loss).
    5. Prepare for Production Run:
      - Data Cleansing: Perform a final round of data cleansing on the production ECC system to ensure data quality before the final CVI run.
      - Downtime Planning: CVI synchronization usually requires some downtime, especially for large volumes.
    6. Go-Live & Hypercare: Monitor CVI synchronization and dependent processes closely after go-live.
Scenario: Your organization has completed a Brownfield S/4HANA conversion to an on-premise system. Post-go-live, users are complaining about slow performance when accessing Fiori apps, and some analytical dashboards are loading very slowly or not at all. Backend transactions (GUI) seem to be performing adequately.
- Q: What are the likely causes for poor Fiori and analytical performance specifically, and what troubleshooting steps would you take using a combination of HANA Studio, Fiori Launchpad, and backend tools?
- A:
  - Likely Causes for Poor Fiori/Analytical Performance:
    1. SAP Gateway/Fiori Frontend Server (FES) Issues:
      - Incorrect Caching: Fiori app caches not invalidated or incorrectly configured.
      - Network Latency: High latency between end-users, FES, and S/4HANA backend.
      - FES Sizing: FES system (where UI5 components and OData services run) is undersized (CPU/RAM).
      - OData Service Performance: The OData services themselves (running on FES or backend) are slow due to inefficient queries.
    2. HANA Database Performance for Analytics:
      - Missing or Outdated Statistics: HANA query optimizer relies heavily on up-to-date statistics.
      - Inefficient CDS Views/Calculation Views: The underlying CDS views (used by Fiori apps) or Calculation Views (for analytical dashboards) are not optimized for HANA (e.g., joins, aggregations).
      - Memory Pressure on HANA: While backend GUI is okay, complex analytical queries might push HANA to its memory limits, leading to paging or slow execution.
      - Expensive Statements: Specific queries for Fiori/analytics are consuming high CPU/memory on HANA.
    3. Backend S/4HANA Application Issues:
      - Missing Indexes: Although HANA is column-store, some specific indexes might still be beneficial for certain query patterns, or compatibility views are not performing as expected.
      - Application Server (ABAP) Sizing: The application servers serving the OData calls might be under-resourced.
    4. Network Configuration:
      - Firewalls, load balancers, or proxies causing delays.
  - Troubleshooting Steps:
    1. Fiori Launchpad and Frontend Server (FES) Side (via Browser Developer Tools, /IWFND/TRACES, /UI2/CACHE_DEL_FULL):
      - Browser Developer Tools (F12): Use the Network tab to identify slow-loading OData calls, UI5 components, or other network requests. Check HTTP status codes for errors.
      - SAP Gateway Trace (/IWFND/TRACES): Activate traces for the problematic Fiori app/user. Analyze the trace to see where the time is spent (on FES, network, or backend).
      - Clear Caches: Invalidate and clear Fiori caches (/UI2/CACHE_DEL_FULL, /UI2/INVAL_CACHES).
      - Check FES System Load: Monitor FES CPU, memory, and work process utilization in ST06/SM50 or OS tools.
    2. HANA Database Side (via HANA Studio/Cockpit):
      - SQL Plan Cache: In HANA Studio, go to Performance -> SQL Plan Cache. Filter for the user or SQL statements executed by the Fiori app/analytics. Look for high EXECUTION_TIME, CPU_TIME, MEMORY_SIZE, LOCK_WAIT_COUNT. Analyze the execution plan for identified expensive statements.
      - Threads: In HANA Studio, go to Performance -> Threads. Look for long-running threads associated with hdbindexserver from the Fiori/analytics user.
      - M_EXPENSIVE_STATEMENTS: Query this view in SQL Console to identify the top N most expensive statements, focusing on those called by Fiori.
      - Statistics: Check M_STATISTICS_LAST_RESET_TIME or use HANA_SQL_Statement_Performance_Statistics_V2.00.093+ (SAP Note 1999993) to ensure statistics are up-to-date. Update statistics for large tables involved in the slow queries.
      - Memory Usage: Check M_SERVICE_MEMORY to see if indexserver is under memory pressure or hitting total_memory_limit.
      - CDS/View Optimization: If a specific CDS view or Calculation View is the bottleneck, investigate its design (e.g., WHERE clause selectivity, join conditions, aggregations). Consider creating appropriate secondary indexes on relevant tables if the query pattern consistently benefits from them (less common for pure column store, but possible).
    3. Backend S/4HANA Application Side (via ST03N, ST22, SM21):
      - Workload Analysis (ST03N): Analyze transaction and OData service response times.
      - ABAP Dumps (ST22) / System Logs (SM21): Check for any backend errors related to the Fiori calls.
      - ABAP Trace (SE30): For specific OData service implementations, perform an ABAP trace to pinpoint slow code sections.
Scenario: Your organization decides on a Greenfield S/4HANA implementation. You are responsible for the data migration, specifically for master data (Customers, Vendors, Materials) and open items (e.g., open sales orders, open purchase orders, open GL items). You decide to use the SAP S/4HANA Migration Cockpit.
- Q: Outline the key steps you would follow using the SAP S/4HANA Migration Cockpit for this data migration, highlighting important considerations for each step.
- A:
  - Key Steps for Data Migration using SAP S/4HANA Migration Cockpit (Staging Tables Approach - Recommended):
    1. Create Migration Project:
      - Action: Access the Migration Cockpit via Fiori Launchpad or transaction LTMC. Create a new migration project, providing a name and selecting "Transfer Data Using Staging Tables" (for on-premise) or "Transfer Data from File" (for cloud, or small on-premise).
      - Consideration: Choose the right transfer method. Staging tables offer more control and better performance for large volumes.
    2. Select Migration Objects:
      - Action: Add the relevant migration objects (e.g., Customer, Vendor, Material, Sales Order, Purchase Order, G/L Open Item) to your project.
      - Consideration: Understand dependencies. E.g., Customer must be migrated before Sales Orders. Ensure all necessary objects are included.
    3. Generate Staging Tables:
      - Action: For each selected migration object, the system generates staging tables in a dedicated schema on the HANA database.
      - Consideration: This requires appropriate database user privileges to create tables in the designated schema.
    4. Extract Data from Source System (ECC) & Prepare:
      - Action: Develop extraction routines (e.g., custom ABAP reports, SAP Data Services, external ETL tools) to pull data from the source ECC system.
      - Consideration: Data Cleansing and Transformation is CRITICAL here. This is where you address data quality issues, apply S/4HANA specific transformations (e.g., currency conversions, new material length, BP consolidation logic, GL account changes), and enrich data.
    5. Load Data into Staging Tables:
      - Action: Use SQL INSERT statements, HANA Studio's data import features, or external ETL tools to load the prepared data into the respective staging tables on the S/4HANA system.
      - Consideration: Ensure data types and formats match the staging table definitions. Handle large volumes efficiently using parallel loads.
    6. Perform Mapping Tasks:
      - Action: In the Migration Cockpit, for each object, go through the "Mapping Tasks" step. This involves value mapping (e.g., old G/L accounts to new G/L accounts, old material types to new) and fixed value tasks (setting default values for fields not present in source).
      - Consideration: This is a crucial functional step. Involve business users/functional consultants to validate mappings rigorously. Missing or incorrect mappings lead to migration errors.
    7. Simulate Migration:
      - Action: Run a simulation for each migration object. This performs all checks and transformations without actual data posting.
      - Consideration: Do NOT skip this step. It helps identify errors early (e.g., data validation errors, missing configuration in S/4HANA, insufficient privileges for the migration user). Address all simulation errors before proceeding.
    8. Migrate Data:
      - Action: After a successful simulation, trigger the actual data migration. The Migration Cockpit calls relevant S/4HANA APIs (e.g., BAPIs, function modules) to post data into the target S/4HANA tables.
      - Consideration: Monitor progress. Handle errors that might occur during actual posting (e.g., data-specific errors that simulation missed). The cockpit provides detailed logs.
    9. Post-Migration Activities & Validation:
      - Action: After migration, perform comprehensive data validation in the S/4HANA system using standard reports, custom queries, and reconciliation tools (especially for financials).
      - Consideration: Verify completeness (all records migrated), accuracy (data values correct), and consistency (relationships between objects maintained). Functional testing of business processes with migrated data.
    10. Close Project:
      - Action: Once all data is migrated and validated, close the migration project in the Cockpit. This typically allows for setting data retention periods for staging tables.
      - Consideration: Housekeeping and cleanup of temporary data.
Scenario: Your Brownfield S/4HANA conversion project is in the custom code adaptation phase. The initial Readiness Check identified a large volume of custom ABAP code (thousands of objects) needing remediation due to Simplification Items and HANA compatibility. Your ABAP team is struggling to keep up with the manual adaptations, leading to project delays.
- Q: What strategies and SAP tools would you leverage to accelerate and streamline the custom code adaptation process in this complex scenario, minimizing manual effort and ensuring quality?
- A:
  - Strategies and SAP Tools to Accelerate Custom Code Adaptation:
    1. Prioritization and Simplification (Critical First Step):
      - Strategy: Don't adapt everything. First, identify and decommission unused custom code. Use Usage Procedure Logging (UPL) or ABAP Call Monitor (ACM) in ECC to track actual code usage over a period.
      - Strategy: For used code, analyze if it can be replaced by standard S/4HANA functionality (e.g., Fiori apps, new transactions, CDS views) or if it aligns with the "Clean Core" principle. If it's a simple report that duplicates standard functionality, decommission it.
      - Tool: SAP provides tools for UPL/ACM analysis and reports to identify unused custom code.
    2. Automated Custom Code Remediation:
      - Strategy: Leverage SAP's tools for automated or semi-automated fixes.
      - Tool: Custom Code Migration Worklist (CMWL): This is a central tool (part of S/4HANA) that integrates with ATC. It provides a worklist of necessary changes, often with quick-fix suggestions or automatic code adjustments for common issues (e.g., SELECT * without ORDER BY, changes to TYPE references, new INSERT statements for ACDOCA).
      - Tool: ABAP Development Tools (ADT) in Eclipse: Many quick fixes and automated refactoring options are available directly in ADT, especially for syntax and simple data type changes.
    3. Centralized Custom Code Analysis with ATC:
      - Strategy: Set up a central ABAP Test Cockpit (ATC) system (preferably a separate instance or on the target S/4HANA system). This allows for consistent and periodic analysis of all custom code across different development streams.
      - Tool: ATC Remote Code Analysis: Perform checks against the source ECC system remotely from the central ATC, generating findings related to S/4HANA readiness.
      - Consideration: Use ATC variants specific to S/4HANA checks (e.g., "S4HANA_READINESS").
    4. Leverage Compatibility Views:
      - Strategy: For custom code that references old table structures (e.g., BKPF, BSEG), SAP provides compatibility views (e.g., V_BKPF, V_BSEG) that redirect to ACDOCA.
      - Consideration: While these reduce immediate adaptation effort, they might not be optimized for performance. Identify custom code heavily relying on these views and consider re-writing them to use ACDOCA directly via CDS views for better performance.
    5. Dedicated Custom Code Adaptation Team/Skillset:
      - Strategy: Ensure you have ABAP developers with specific expertise in S/4HANA custom code adaptation (understanding SELECT * implications, new data models, CDS consumption).
      - Strategy: Consider external consultants specializing in custom code migration if internal resources are limited.
    6. Iterative and Phased Approach:
      - Strategy: Don't try to adapt everything at once. Focus on business-critical reports and functionalities first. Adapt in phases, tied to testing cycles.
      - Consideration: Use the Custom Code Adaptation App (Fiori) or CMWL to manage work packages.
    7. Training and Knowledge Transfer:
      - Strategy: Train ABAP developers on S/4HANA programming guidelines, Clean Core principles, and the effective use of ADT, ATC, and CMWL.
      - Tool: SAP Learning Hub, openSAP courses.

By combining rigorous analysis and prioritization with the intelligent use of SAP's specialized tools, organizations can significantly streamline the custom code adaptation phase and mitigate project delays.

Rakshit Ranjan Singh

Search This Blog